Thread:71.60.4.94/@comment-24.89.197.31-20120417214234/@comment-1934311-20120421224350

Since this discussion doesn't have a clear outcome, here's my opinion.

Darkseid - I agree there is no need for pages related to individual articles of clothing. Any information about Cad Bane's hats would be better off in the equipment section of the Cad Bane article. Articles relating to individual items should be kept only if they are significant to the plots of the episodes like Mortis Dagger or Jedi Holocron

As for unidentified characters, I agree as well. They should only be kept unless they at least have a minor role in an episode, like Unidentified Lutrillian prisoner. Unidentified articles like Unidentified 501st ARF Trooper (Umbara) should be deleted.

Bane7670 - I can see how it could possibly improve organization, but it's impractical to have so many articles on topics with little to no significance. Imagine if we had articles for every character's equipment/clothing (ex. Rex's helmet, Rex's DC-17 hand blasters, Rex's Pauldron). There would basically be no need for equipment/appearance sections. I don't mind breaking "traditional wikia format", or having more articles, but It's just too odd to me. for example, If I were a visitor and wanted to look for information related to Cad Bane's weapons, it would be common sense for me to type in Cad Bane in the search box, not Cad Bane's blasters.

I do believe technology articles with sufficient background information should be kept, especially if they are mass produced and, once again, have significance. Phase II Clone Trooper Armor is a great example: there is a lot of noteworthy cannonical information, and it makes many appearances. Embo's hat, however: there is little to say about it besides the fact that it was worn and thrown by Embo. We do not need to delete this information, but it would be neater to move it to the Embo article. If there was more information on his hat, such as where his type of hat was produced, it could possibly deserve its own article.